Picture this: Your neighbor climbs into an ice bath at 6 AM, filming their “morning wellness ritual.” They’ll tell you it reduces inflammation, boosts immunity, and transforms their health. And they’re not alone. Ice bath sales skyrocketed from under 1,000 units in November 2022 to more than 90,000 just one year later.

But here’s what makes the trend interesting. A new comprehensive analysis of the research suggests a much more nuanced picture of what cold water immersion is actually doing inside the body. While millions swear by the benefits, the underlying physiological responses don’t always match the popular narrative.

One of the clearest findings across studies is that cold water immersion triggers an acute increase in inflammatory markers. Instead of reducing inflammation immediately, the body appears to mount a stress response that elevates these markers for at least an hour afterward.

The meta-analysis found:
• Immediate inflammation increase: SMD 1.03
• 1-hour increase: SMD 1.26

This doesn’t mean cold exposure is harmful. Rather, it reflects the body’s natural reaction to cold stress. Researchers suggest these short-term changes may be tied to metabolic processes like glycogenolysis rather than long-lasting systemic inflammation. Still, it's a reminder that the immediate effects of cold exposure differ from what many people assume.

Popular advice often suggests that cold water immersion reduces stress. The evidence shows something more time-dependent.

Across the studies:
• No significant reduction in stress immediately, 1 hour, 24 hours, or 48 hours after exposure
• A meaningful decrease at 12 hours post-immersion (SMD –1.00)

This delayed effect hints that the body may transition from an initial cold-shock sympathetic response into a later parasympathetic recovery phase. Many people feel energized right after an ice bath, but the actual stress-regulation benefits may not appear until much later in the day.

This doesn’t mean cold exposure is ineffective. It simply means the timing of benefits may be different than expected.

Immune claims are everywhere in the cold exposure world, yet the short-term evidence doesn’t show clear immediate changes in immune markers.

What the research does show is interesting:
• No significant immune changes immediately or one hour post-exposure
• A 30-day cold shower routine resulted in 29 percent fewer sickness absence days in one large trial
• Yet the total number of actual “illness days” did not differ between groups

This suggests people may feel better or more resilient, even if objective illness measures don’t shift much. Longer-term immune adaptations remain a possibility, but the current evidence is mixed and not definitive.

The research highlights that cold water immersion has time-dependent and context-dependent effects.

Here’s what the evidence supports:

If stress reduction is your goal:
• Morning cold exposure may improve stress later that evening
• Evening exposure may support next-day stress levels

The benefits don’t occur immediately but seem to emerge over a 12-hour window.

One study found improvements in sleep quality, particularly when cold exposure followed heat training or intense physical activity.

It’s promising, but the evidence is still limited.

A large study found small improvements in mental quality-of-life scores after 30 days of cold showers.
These effects faded by 90 days, which may reflect reduced novelty or inconsistent adherence.

Cold exposure adds an acute inflammatory stimulus.
Healthy individuals generally tolerate this well, but those with chronic inflammatory conditions may want to approach cautiously or consult a clinician.

If you’re experimenting with cold exposure, use the timing insights from the research instead of the common wellness assumptions.

Try the following:

• Start with 30 seconds to 2 minutes at 10–15°C
• Track your stress levels immediately, then at 4, 8, and 12 hours
• Pay attention to changes in sleep and recovery
• Don’t expect immediate inflammation reduction
• Consider consistency if you're exploring potential immune-related benefits

Cold water immersion isn’t an instant cure-all, but it may offer meaningful stress-regulation and wellbeing benefits when used intentionally and consistently.

The key is understanding when the effects occur and adjusting your expectations accordingly.

This is just the beginning. If you want to dive deeper into the specific techniques that separate good athletes from great ones, check out The Visualization Handbook for Elite Athletes. It contains the complete frameworks and exercises used by world-class performers like Michael Phelps, Novak Djokovic, Jack Nicklaus, and Lindsey Vonn: https://amzn.to/4b4za4U